Trademark Infringement: What to Do If Someone Copies You

Introduction

Discovering that another business is using a trademark confusingly similar to yours can be alarming and frustrating. Trademark infringement occurs when an unauthorized party uses a trademark that is identical or confusingly similar to your registered or unregistered trademark in connection with goods or services, potentially causing consumer confusion.

Brand protection is crucial for businesses of all sizes because your trademark represents years of investment in building customer recognition, trust, and market position. When someone infringes on your trademark, they’re essentially stealing the goodwill you’ve worked hard to establish while potentially damaging your reputation and diverting customers away from your business.

This comprehensive guide is essential for business owners, entrepreneurs, marketing professionals, and anyone who has invested in building a brand. Whether you’re a startup founder who just launched your first product or an established company facing infringement issues, understanding how to identify, address, and prevent trademark infringement will help protect one of your most valuable business assets.

Understanding the Basics

What Constitutes Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement fundamentally involves the unauthorized use of a trademark that creates a likelihood of confusion among consumers. This confusion can occur in several ways: consumers might believe the infringing product comes from the same source as your trademarked goods, that there’s some affiliation between the businesses, or that your company has endorsed or sponsored the infringing product.

The legal test for infringement doesn’t require identical marks. Courts evaluate the overall commercial impression and consider factors like the similarity of the marks, the relatedness of the goods or services, the channels of trade, the sophistication of consumers, and evidence of actual confusion.

How Trademark Rights Are Established

Trademark rights in the United States can be established in two primary ways: through use in commerce or through federal registration. Under common law, you acquire limited rights to a trademark simply by using it in commerce within a specific geographic area. These “common law” rights are generally limited to the geographic regions where you’ve established goodwill through actual use.

Federal trademark registration through the USPTO provides much stronger, nationwide protection. Registration creates a legal presumption of ownership and validity, gives you the exclusive right to use the mark nationwide in connection with the goods/services listed in your registration, and provides important legal advantages in infringement cases.

Types of Trademark Protection

Word Marks: These protect the words, letters, or numbers that make up your trademark, regardless of font, style, or color. For example, “COCA-COLA” as a word mark would be protected regardless of how it’s stylized.

Design Marks: These protect logos, symbols, or stylized text presentations. The protection extends to the specific visual appearance of the mark.

Combined Marks: These protect both word and design elements together as they appear in the registration.

Trade Dress: This broader category can protect the overall appearance and packaging of products, including color schemes, shapes, and distinctive design elements that identify the source of goods.

The Process

Step 1: Document the Infringement

Begin by thoroughly documenting the alleged infringement. Take screenshots of websites, save advertisements, purchase samples of infringing products, and note dates, locations, and circumstances of the infringement. Create a detailed timeline showing when you first used your trademark, when you registered it (if applicable), and when the infringement began.

Gather evidence of your trademark’s use, including marketing materials, sales records, and any customer feedback that demonstrates recognition of your brand. If you have a federal registration, compile your registration certificate and renewal documents.

Step 2: Analyze the Strength of Your Case

Evaluate whether you have valid trademark rights and whether infringement has actually occurred. Consider the similarity between the marks, the relatedness of the goods or services, and whether consumers are likely to be confused. A trademark attorney can provide valuable guidance during this analysis phase.

Research the alleged infringer’s business to understand their use of the mark, when they started using it, and in what geographic areas. This information will be crucial for determining your legal options and negotiating position.

Step 3: Cease and Desist Letter

Most trademark infringement cases begin with a cease and desist letter. This formal notice informs the infringer of your trademark rights and demands they stop using the infringing mark. A well-crafted letter can resolve many disputes without litigation while preserving your legal rights.

The letter should clearly identify your trademark rights, provide specific details about the infringement, explain why their use is likely to cause confusion, and demand specific actions within a reasonable timeframe. Including a copy of your trademark registration (if applicable) strengthens your position.

Step 4: Negotiation and Settlement

If the infringer responds positively to your cease and desist letter, you may be able to resolve the matter through negotiation. Settlement options might include the infringer agreeing to stop using the mark, modifying their mark to eliminate confusion, limiting their use to specific geographic areas or product categories, or paying damages.

Document any settlement agreement in writing and consider including provisions for ongoing monitoring and enforcement. A coexistence agreement might be appropriate in some cases where both parties can use similar marks without causing confusion.

Timeline Expectations

The timeline for resolving trademark infringement varies significantly based on the complexity of the case and the infringer’s response. A cease and desist letter might resolve simple cases within 30-60 days. If litigation becomes necessary, federal trademark lawsuits typically take 12-24 months or longer to resolve, though preliminary injunctions can provide faster relief in urgent situations.

Requirements

Establishing Your Rights

To successfully pursue a trademark infringement claim, you must first establish that you have valid trademark rights. For unregistered trademarks, you need to prove you were the first to use the mark in commerce and that you’ve continued using it. For registered trademarks, your registration certificate provides strong evidence of ownership and validity.

Your trademark must also be distinctive, meaning it identifies and distinguishes your goods or services from others in the marketplace. Generic terms cannot be trademarked, and descriptive terms generally require proof of acquired distinctiveness through extensive use.

USPTO Requirements for Registered Marks

If you have a federal trademark registration, ensure it remains in good standing by filing required maintenance documents. You must file a Declaration of Continued Use (Section 8) between the 5th and 6th year after registration, and then between the 9th and 10th year, combined with a Declaration of Incontestability (Section 15) if eligible.

Renewal applications must be filed every ten years to maintain your registration. Failure to file these documents will result in cancellation of your registration and loss of the benefits federal registration provides.

Evidence Requirements

Strong infringement cases require substantial evidence of both your trademark rights and the likelihood of confusion. Collect evidence of your mark’s commercial use, consumer recognition surveys if available, and documentation of any actual confusion that has occurred.

Evidence of the infringer’s use should include samples of their products, marketing materials, and information about their distribution channels and customer base. The more comprehensive your evidence, the stronger your position in negotiations or litigation.

Costs Involved

Initial Assessment and Cease and Desist

Hiring a trademark attorney to assess your case and prepare a cease and desist letter typically costs between $1,000-$3,000. This initial investment often resolves disputes efficiently and can save substantial costs compared to litigation.

Some businesses attempt to handle cease and desist letters themselves, but attorney involvement generally produces better results and reduces the risk of making statements that could weaken your position in future proceedings.

Federal Court Litigation

If litigation becomes necessary, costs can range from $50,000-$200,000 or more for a case that goes to trial. However, many cases settle before trial, which can significantly reduce costs. Factors affecting litigation costs include the complexity of the case, the amount of discovery required, whether expert witnesses are needed, and the duration of the proceedings.

Some cases may qualify for preliminary injunction relief, which can resolve matters more quickly but still involves significant legal fees, typically ranging from $15,000-$50,000.

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Mediation and arbitration can provide less expensive alternatives to federal court litigation, with costs typically ranging from $10,000-$30,000 depending on the complexity of the issues and the experience level of the neutral parties involved.

Ongoing Enforcement Costs

Budget for ongoing trademark monitoring services, which typically cost $200-$1,000 annually depending on the scope of monitoring. These services alert you to potential infringers early, when resolution is typically easier and less expensive.

Common Challenges

Proving Likelihood of Confusion

The most significant challenge in trademark infringement cases is proving that consumers are likely to be confused by the allegedly infringing use. Courts consider multiple factors, and the analysis can be complex and fact-specific.

Overcome this challenge by gathering strong evidence of similarity between the marks, relatedness of the goods or services, overlap in marketing channels and customer base, and any evidence of actual confusion. Consumer surveys conducted by qualified experts can provide powerful evidence, though they’re expensive to conduct properly.

Defending Against Invalidity Claims

Infringers often respond to infringement claims by challenging the validity of your trademark rights. They might argue your mark is generic or merely descriptive, that you’ve abandoned it through non-use, or that your registration was obtained improperly.

Prepare for these challenges by maintaining comprehensive records of your trademark’s use, avoiding generic use of your mark in marketing materials, and ensuring your trademark registrations accurately reflect your actual use of the mark.

Geographic Limitations

If you only have common law trademark rights, your protection may be limited to the geographic areas where you’ve established goodwill through actual use. An infringer operating in different geographic markets might have superior rights in their territory.

Consider federal trademark registration to obtain nationwide priority and protection. If geographic limitations are an issue, focus your enforcement efforts on areas where you have established rights and develop a strategy for expanding your geographic presence.

International Infringement

Pursuing infringers operating in other countries presents unique challenges, including different legal systems, language barriers, and varying enforcement mechanisms. Many countries require local trademark registration for effective enforcement.

Work with trademark attorneys experienced in international enforcement and consider filing trademark applications in key international markets where you do business or plan to expand.

Protecting Your Rights

Proactive Monitoring

Implement a comprehensive trademark monitoring strategy to identify potential infringers early. This includes regular searches of the USPTO database for conflicting applications, monitoring domain name registrations, and surveilling major e-commerce platforms where counterfeit goods might be sold.

Set up Google Alerts for your trademarks and regularly search social media platforms where unauthorized use might occur. The earlier you identify potential infringement, the easier and less expensive it typically is to resolve.

Consistent Use and Enforcement

Use your trademarks consistently and in accordance with proper trademark usage guidelines. Always use your registered trademarks with the ® symbol and unregistered marks with the ™ symbol. Avoid using your trademarks as generic terms and maintain quality control over any licensed uses.

Develop and implement a consistent enforcement policy. Failing to enforce your trademark rights against some infringers can weaken your position against others and may even result in loss of your trademark rights through abandonment.

Documentation and Record-Keeping

Maintain comprehensive records of your trademark use, including dated examples of marketing materials, product packaging, advertising campaigns, and sales records. These documents may be crucial evidence in enforcement proceedings.

Keep records of your enforcement activities, including cease and desist letters sent, responses received, and actions taken. This documentation demonstrates your commitment to protecting your trademark rights and can support claims for enhanced damages in appropriate cases.

International Protection

If you do business internationally or plan to expand internationally, consider filing trademark applications in key countries where protection is needed. The Madrid Protocol provides a streamlined process for filing trademark applications in multiple countries through a single application.

Remember that trademark rights are generally territorial, meaning you need protection in each country where you want to prevent others from using your mark. Develop an international filing strategy that aligns with your business expansion plans and budget constraints.

FAQ

Q: How do I know if someone is infringing my trademark?
A: Trademark infringement occurs when someone uses a mark that is identical or confusingly similar to yours in connection with related goods or services, creating a likelihood of consumer confusion. Look for similarities in the marks themselves, the relatedness of the products or services, overlapping customer bases, and similar marketing channels. If consumers might reasonably believe the products come from the same source or that there’s some business relationship between you and the other user, infringement may have occurred.

Q: What’s the difference between trademark infringement and trademark dilution?
A: Trademark infringement requires likelihood of confusion between similar marks used on related goods or services. Trademark dilution, available only for famous marks, protects against uses that blur the distinctiveness of the famous mark or tarnish its reputation, even when there’s no likelihood of confusion. For example, if someone used “McDonald’s” for legal services, it wouldn’t cause confusion, but it might dilute the McDonald’s brand through blurring.

Q: Can I stop someone from using my business name if I haven’t registered it as a trademark?
A: You may have common law trademark rights in your business name if you’ve used it in commerce to identify your goods or services. However, these rights are typically limited to the geographic areas where you’ve established goodwill through actual use. Federal trademark registration provides much stronger, nationwide protection. If someone is using your unregistered business name in a way that causes consumer confusion, you may still have legal recourse, but it will be more challenging to enforce than a registered trademark.

Q: How long does it take to resolve a trademark infringement case?
A: The timeline varies significantly based on the infringer’s response and the complexity of the case. A cease and desist letter might resolve simple cases within 30-60 days if the infringer cooperates. If the matter proceeds to federal court litigation, cases typically take 12-24 months or longer to fully resolve. However, you may be able to obtain preliminary injunction relief within a few months in cases involving clear infringement and irreparable harm.

Q: What damages can I recover in a trademark infringement lawsuit?
A: Trademark law provides several types of monetary relief: the infringer’s profits from the infringement, your actual damages (such as lost sales or harm to reputation), and in cases of willful infringement, enhanced damages and attorney’s fees. You can also seek non-monetary relief, including injunctions stopping the infringement, destruction of infringing products, and corrective advertising. The specific remedies available depend on the facts of your case and whether your trademark is registered.

Conclusion

Trademark infringement can pose a serious threat to your business, but understanding your rights and taking prompt, appropriate action can help protect your valuable brand assets. The key to successful trademark enforcement is early detection, thorough documentation, and strategic response tailored to the specific circumstances of each case.

Remember that trademark rights require active protection – they don’t enforce themselves. Implementing a proactive monitoring and enforcement strategy will help ensure your trademarks continue to serve as valuable business assets that distinguish your goods and services in the marketplace.

While some trademark disputes can be resolved through direct negotiation, many cases benefit from professional legal guidance to navigate the complex requirements of trademark law and achieve the best possible outcome for your business.

—

Ready to protect your business and intellectual property? LegalZone.com has helped thousands of entrepreneurs form LLCs, corporations, and nonprofits while protecting their most valuable assets. Our experienced team offers affordable pricing, fast turnaround, and expert support throughout the business formation and trademark protection process. Whether you’re starting a new venture or need to protect an existing brand, we’re here to help you build a strong legal foundation for your business success. Contact LegalZone.com today to get started with professional formation services and comprehensive trademark protection.